Trade Advice

[koralkillers]

I have been offered S.Davis and C.Brown for P.holmes

 

12 team standard performance league w/ 12 man rosters,you can start 3RB 2/WR or 3Wr/2RB I always prefer starting 3RB,My team listed below and thanks for any input.

 

QB-C.Palmer

 

RB's-P.Holmes,A.Green,J.Arrington,C.Benson,J.Bettis

 

WR's-N.Burleson,T.J Housmanzadeh,K.Mccardell,Tony Gonzalas

 

DEF-N.E

 

K-Vinatieri

Edited September 27, 2005 by koralkillers

[Chavez]

Davis looks to be 100% from his injury. In swapping Holmes for Brown, it's a super-productive RB who has an injury history vs a very good RB who seems extremely injury-prone.

 

I think the trade is fair; you have to decide if you think riding Priest, who's aging and has had significant injuries the past couple years, is better than getting TWO RBs who are healthy now but have injury issues themselves.

 

I like depth, I would strongly consider pulling the trigger.

[seminoles]

i don't like it. you are giving up a starter for two spot starters. no like.

[koralkillers]

Davis looks to be 100% from his injury. In swapping Holmes for Brown, it's a super-productive RB who has an injury history vs a very good RB who seems extremely injury-prone.

 

I think the trade is fair; you have to decide if you think riding Priest, who's aging and has had significant injuries the past couple years, is better than getting TWO RBs who are healthy now but have injury issues themselves.

 

I like depth, I would strongly consider pulling the trigger.

 

1026064[/snapback]

 

 

 

 

thanks for the input,he has now offered me W.Dunn and C.brown for Priest and T.J

He says he wont do Dunn and Brown for Priest but if I can get him to do that is that better than Davis and Brown or is it a toss up?He really wants Priest bad.

[Chavez]

Age concerns and all, I'd rather have Davis and Brown but Dunn doesn't suck, if that's the best you can get.

[I Like Soup]

I would rather have Davis/Brown then Dunn/Brown. But if you get points for receptions Dunn could be considered. And I don't agree with Seminoles, since you can start three RBs, these two guys producing on your starting lineup could be better than Priest...he is getting older and LJ is getting in to the mix.