Should I make this trade?

[chiefloganpsu]

Not sure if I should pull the trigger on this one?

 

I was offered P. Manning, J. Smith and T. Fisher for

Hasselbeck, S. Jackson and Lelie.

 

My team

 

QB - Hass, Holcomb

RB - Alexander, SJax, Caddy, M. Barber

WR- R. Moss, Coles, Lelie, Moulds, Engram

Other positions not involved.

 

His team

 

QB - Peyton, Leftwich

RB - Jordan, C. Brown, C. Perry, T. Fisher, Duckett

WR- TO, Branch, J. Smith, Stallworth, Randle El,

Chatman

 

Standard performance scoring league with 2 RB, 2 WR

and RB/WR flex.

 

His offer was actually a counter-offer where I

included Caddy instead of SJax. I like the upgrade at

QB and WR, but I'm worried about RB depth if I give up

SJax. Caddy is going to be in and out of the shop, it

seems, and Barber is just a spot starter. I also worry

about missing out on the fact that SJax is going to be

getting 20 carries now that Martz is out.

 

Any thoughts?

[chipsjake]

I'd do it. You start Caddy, lose some depth but Manning and Jimmy Smith go right into your lineup. I like it.

[Zooty]

Not sure if I should pull the trigger on this one?

 

I was offered P. Manning, J. Smith and T. Fisher for

Hasselbeck, S. Jackson and Lelie.

 

 

 

1103920[/snapback]

 

 

 

No way.

QBs are a wash. This is the '05 Manning. You get a better WR but you already have 2 good ones and downgrade at RB. This means your flex player will switch from a RB to a WR and thus less points that won't be made up weekly by your change at QB.

 

No deal

[weekapaug]

I also think the QBS are a wash. Hass has a very nice schedule coming up. While I think Manning will start opening things up as they get to some tougher teams where they will need to throw more, Hass should keep pace.

 

With that, I think this trade doesn't really help you, and it does help your opponent. Pass.