I need unbiased inteligent opinions on this trade

[matty650]

Ok here we go I'm in a 10 team 41 roster spot keeper league with IDP and no head to head 19 starters 1qb 2rb 3wr 1te 1k 4dl 3lb 4 db. Ok now I need opinions and thank you by the way

 

Team A Team B

qb j russell oak qb b farve gb

rb d mcfadden 08 rb s alexander sea

wr v jackson sd wr j galloway tb

lb d johnson kc lb d smith jags

db c harris db a bethea ind

 

ok 5 for 5 give me your best opinions on this trade (thank you)

players already on new teams so tell me which team is stronger at the positions and why

Edited November 23, 2007 by matty650

[Grits and Shins]

I don't do IDP so I can't really evaluate how the defensive players might balance the offensive players.

 

But the fact that this is a keeper league just means that team B is trading old players that might help team A win now for younger players to build his future team with.

 

I would speculate that Team B is out of the playoffs.

 

I see nothing wrong here.

[CowboysDiehard]

" I need unbiased inteligent opinions on this trade"

 

And you're looking for them here?

[Tford]

Hopefully, Team A is making a run at the championship. But I have two questions.

 

1) Why trade for Shaun Alexander? I wouldn't be surprised if Shaun doesn't turn in another decent game this year.

2) Team A better have other decent IDPs on his team after giving up the better LB and DB in the trade. D Smith and Bethea aren't upgrades from what he gave up.

 

Personally, I don't think A got enough in return for Russell and McFadden. Bad trade for A, good trade for B IMO.