#1 in a dynasty draft.

[buiznitch]

I know the draft hasn't happened yet but just want to know is McFadden a lock or who would go with someone else. Then revisit this after the draft and see the opinions then.

[MrTed46]

I know the draft hasn't happened yet but just want to know is McFadden a lock or who would go with someone else. Then revisit this after the draft and see the opinions then.

 

 

No doubt McFadden

[Savage Beatings]

I like McFadden, but not a lock IMO for #1. It really depends upon how the NFL draft goes tomorrow. If Stewart or Mendenhall end up in a better team situation (where they might produce as a starting RB right away), then I wouldn't be afraid to take either of them with the #1 pick. But I would say that it is for sure between those three. All things being equal before knowing their team situtions, McFadden goes first.

[budlitebrad]

I like McFadden, but not a lock IMO for #1. It really depends upon how the NFL draft goes tomorrow. If Stewart or Mendenhall end up in a better team situation (where they might produce as a starting RB right away), then I wouldn't be afraid to take either of them with the #1 pick. But I would say that it is for sure between those three. All things being equal before knowing their team situtions, McFadden goes first.

 

+1

[CMac83]

I disagree that McFadden should be the #1 pick. I think Jonathan Stewart is a better all-around back. Plus, with McFadden's questionable strength, he might never get the looks at the stripe.

 

I'm of the opinion that it should be Stewart unless McFadden ends up in a drastically better situation, and not vice versa.