Is Gates worth keeping?

[Largent]

6pt's for TD, 1pt per 10yrds. 10 team league.

 

I have a small keeper question. Gates and I pass my 6th round pick and keep him. Not sure, he burned me a few times last season with some stinkers when I needed just a moderate game to win. He's healthy this year, but the weapons around him are better. Word from camp is he's bigger with less body fat and has his ankles/toes back.

 

OR

 

I keep Carlson for my 15th round keeper. Star in camp so far, bit of an unknown with Knapp and Houshmazili there this season, but Hassel is healthy and will likely rely on him if TJ draws the coverage in the middle.

 

Thanks

[Fighting Milk Cows]

6pt's for TD, 1pt per 10yrds. 10 team league.

 

I have a small keeper question. Gates and I pass my 6th round pick and keep him. Not sure, he burned me a few times last season with some stinkers when I needed just a moderate game to win. He's healthy this year, but the weapons around him are better. Word from camp is he's bigger with less body fat and has his ankles/toes back.

 

OR

 

I keep Carlson for my 15th round keeper. Star in camp so far, bit of an unknown with Knapp and Houshmazili there this season, but Hassel is healthy and will likely rely on him if TJ draws the coverage in the middle.

 

Thanks

 

 

Gates is still the best TE, there is a lot of seperation between him and the pack so he is worth keeping at #6

[Big Country]

While I do like the upside of Carlson, barring injury I do not see him coming clos to Gates' production, and would also advise towards keeping gates.

[Donutrun Jellies]

I agree with Big Country ... would love Carlson in the 15th, but would take Gates in the 6th -- as the other folks available in the 6th won't give you the competitive advantage a healthy Gates should bring. If this was Gates in the 3rd, I would go Carlson. 6th? I take Gates.