Which IDP Keeper?

[PlayaHata]

Our league is allowing us to keep one offensive player and one defensive player this year. I've narrowed my IDP choices to Charles Grant or Donnie Edwards.

 

Scoring is

Tackles = 1 pt

Sacks = 3 pts

Safety = 3 pts

Interception = 3 pts

Fumble Recovery = 3 pts

Blocked kicks (FG, XP, punts) = 3 pts

Forced Fumble = 1 pt

Pass Defensed = 1 pts

TD = 6 pts

 

Thanks in advance for your input.

 

P.S. If this belongs in FFA, let me know and I'll ask to have it moved. I didn't see any IDP discussion over there so thought I'd start here.

[gilthorp]

In a similar scoring system, Edwards outscored Grant by 65 points last year in my local.

 

This is a no-brainer IMO.

 

If you are capable of keeping an IDP, it had better be a LB.

[darin3]

Edwards, complete and utter no brainer.

[PlayaHata]

Thanks for the quick response. Only second year of IDP, so sorry if it seemed like a dumb question!

 

[darin3]

Thanks for the quick response.  Only second year of IDP, so sorry if it seemed like a dumb question!

 

 

906489[/snapback]

 

 

 

No problem...

 

LBs are the biggest scorers on the IDP side... sort of like RBs on the offensive side. If you have one of the best LBs (Lewis, Edwards, Bulluck), you are off to a good start.

 

A good DL guy like Grant is hard to come by, but DL's scoring is typically erratic.

 

Gotta keep Edwards... he's a top-3, if not THE top - LB.