Depends a little on your scoring system, i.e. if you get rewarded well for yardage and/or length of touchdown v. standard performance PPR. In my league where we have huge bonuses for total yards and TDs over 25 and 50 yards, T. Hill was our leagues top point getter, even above McCaffrey.
However, assuming you're in a typically scored 12 team PPR league and each owner keeps 1 player, I might lean Rice as well.